Buttonwood Bay isn’t just a picturesque waterfront neighborhood in Key Largo, FL—it’s also an under-the-radar hotspot for incredible eats, vibrant food stops, and the kind of hidden culinary gems savvy locals dream about. Whether you’re weaving along US-1 or exploring the quieter byways near the marina, the dining scene around Buttonwood Bay promises delicious diversity, incredible views, and the sort of neighborly warmth that keeps visitors and residents coming back for seconds.
The Heart of Buttonwood Bay: Dining Along US-1
Most of Buttonwood Bay’s culinary action is clustered along US-1, just a stone’s throw from mile markers 96–97. Here, you’ll find a cheerful mix of casual clam shacks, inventive bistros, and breezy cafes.
- Key Largo Fisheries Backyard Café (1313 Ocean Bay Dr)
If you want a true taste of Key Largo’s rich seafood tradition, this is hands-down a can’t-miss. Set in a waterfront marina with picnic tables overlooking the boats, the Fisheries Backyard Café is renowned for its sprawling menu of just-caught local favorites: conch fritters, fish sandwiches, stone crab claws, and creamy Key lime pie. Prices range from $10-$25 per entree, making it accessible for families and solo diners alike. The vibe is salt-air casual, and the sunsets? Unbeatable.
- Doc’s Diner (99696 Overseas Hwy)
A local institution, Doc’s Diner radiates classic Florida hospitality and serves up hearty breakfasts and lunches from 6 a.m. to 2 p.m. daily. Try the “Fisherman’s Special” with homemade grits, or go for stacked pancakes and locally-roasted coffee. The prices here are wallet-friendly ($8–$15 per plate), and the staff greet you like family. Take a seat at the counter or grab a booth and soak in the neighborhood flavor.
Savoring Global Flavors: Diverse Bites Just Steps Away
Buttonwood Bay may be small, but its food scene is deliciously diverse, reflecting Key Largo’s vibrant mix of cultures and tastes.
- Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen (99336 Overseas Hwy)
A bright pink building overflowing with funky island memorabilia, Mrs. Mac’s is as famous for its fish tacos and tangy chili ($12–$22 per entree) as for its world-famous Key Lime Freeze—a slushy, tart treat perfect for hot afternoons. Locals swear by the coconut shrimp and daily specials; tourists return for the warm service and unbeatable kitsch.
- Num Thai Sushi & Noodle Bar (103200 Overseas Hwy, Suite 10)
Tucked into a cozy plaza just north of Buttonwood Bay, Num Thai brings creative sushi rolls and flavorful noodle dishes to the neighborhood. Try the yellowtail jalapeño roll or spicy drunken noodles, and don’t miss the sake cocktails. Entrees are typically $15–$28, and the sleek décor makes for a fun dinner spot after a day on the water.
- La Marea (On-site at Playa Largo Resort, 97450 Overseas Hwy)
For a refined evening meal, La Marea delivers modern coastal cuisine in a stunning resort setting right across US-1 from Buttonwood Bay. Think roasted local catch, saffron risotto, and artisan desserts ($25–$40 per plate). The wine list and ocean views make this a go-to for date nights or celebrations.
Sweet Stops: Bakeries & Coffeehouses
- Harriette’s Restaurant (95710 Overseas Hwy)
Technically a short drive north from Buttonwood Bay, this beloved bakery-café is worth the extra minutes. Famous for sky-high muffins in rotating flavors (key lime, guava, blueberry, chocolate chip—the works!), Harriette’s also serves downhome breakfasts, strong coffee, and sinfully good desserts. Prices range from $3 for a muffin to $12 for a full breakfast.
- Sunshine Café (103200 Overseas Hwy)
Nestled in the same plaza as Num Thai, the Sunshine Café is the best-kept secret for a mid-morning pick-me-up. Enjoy flaky pastries, strong espressos, and savory quiches in a laid-back, sunlit space. Locals love the Cuban coffee and guava-cheese pastries for under $8.
Hidden Gems & Local Favorites
- Arlos Bistro Food Truck (usually parked near Atlantic Dr & US-1)
Don’t blink or you’ll miss Arlos, a food truck slinging the best Cuban sandwiches and mojo pork bowls in the neighborhood. Everything is made from scratch, and the prices ($10–$15) are unbeatable for the flavor punch.
- Lazy Lobster Seafood Restaurant (102770 Overseas Hwy)
A few blocks up, Lazy Lobster remains a favorite for its airy patio, fresh-caught lobster, and rotating craft beers. Order the lobster Reuben or seafood paella, and don’t forget their homemade hot sauce. Entrees run $18–$32, and the crowded Friday night scene is proof of its local appeal.
The Buttonwood Bay Food Scene: More Than Just a Meal
What sets Buttonwood Bay’s food scene apart is its blend of indoor comfort and outdoor Old Florida charm. Many spots feature alfresco seating—ideal for enjoying the breezy salt air. While seafood naturally reigns, you’ll also find a growing selection of international flavors and fusion eateries stepping up their game.
Price-wise, the neighborhood offers something for every budget: grab-and-go food trucks for casual bites, family-friendly diners, beloved mid-range mainstays, and special occasion fine dining—all within a mile.
The community-oriented atmosphere means you’ll rarely wait long for a friendly smile or a story about the day’s catch. This is the quintessential Key Largo dining experience: fresh, flavorful, and always a little bit fun.
Pro Tips & Local Traditions
- Don’t miss the local happy hour “appetizer crawls” between Mrs. Mac’s, Doc’s Diner, and Lazy Lobster—just follow the locals and sample the specialty snacks and cocktails at each stop on a breezy afternoon.
- Key lime pie is a must-order dessert everywhere you go. Each spot has its signature twist, from classic graham crusts to nutty toppings.
- Many Buttonwood Bay restaurants are pet-friendly on patios, so bring your furry friend!
Whether you’re settling in for a sunset dinner, grabbing a morning muffin for your kayak excursion, or discovering a new lunch favorite, Buttonwood Bay’s food scene is a Key Largo secret worth savoring—one delicious bite at a time.